With metal roofing becoming more and more popular, many homeowners and potential new roof buyers are starting to wonder exactly why, and rightly so – the roof is one of the most important features of a home considering it endures harsh weather, leaks can cause huge issues, and repairs can be very expensive. If you are in the market for a new roof or are simply curious about your options, we are here to help you learn the differences between metal roofs and traditional shingle roofs while weighing the pros and cons of each to discover which is best for you.
Longevity and Durability
When it comes to longevity, metal roofs have been shown to last up to 50 years while the traditional shingle roof shows a lifetime of less than half that of the metal roof at only about 20 years. According to State Farm insurance, “some metal roofs can sustain wind gusts up to 140 miles per hour, will not corrode or crack, and may be impact-resistant (depending on which metal you choose),” while HomeAdvisor.com insinuates that although shingle roofing is less expensive, in the end, you get what you pay for, stating “cheap materials aren’t built to hold up well to sun exposure, rapid temperature changes, high winds, or extreme weather events like hail storms.” It looks like the metal roof is the winner of this category.
The Oak Ridge National Laboratory conducted a study on the energy savings of metal roofs vs shingle roofs and found that all three tests conducted proved that the metal roof showed significant energy savings compared to the traditional shingle roof. When it comes to cost-effectiveness, traditional shingle roofs are more cost effective short term with a lower installation cost of around $9,000 while metal roofs average $18,000 (Hipporoof.com). However, as we noted in the durability category previously, metal roofs outlast shingle roofs to create a 1.5x less expensive lifetime cost, with the ultimate conclusion that both are cost-effective depending on your needs at the time. The metal roof may come out slightly ahead in this category.
HomeTips.com states “because of [metal’s] long-term durability, the trick is that you ultimately save the difference (and more) if you stay in the house for a long time and, of course, you save on seasonal maintenance.” When a metal roof needs a repair, it may be a little more difficult to find a contractor in the area who is readily available and able to repair it, however the general consensus is that metal roofs come with less need for maintenance and repairs than shingles do, so it looks like metal roofing comes out on top again.
In conclusion, each homeowner will have to decide which roofing material is best for them, but in general, metal appears to be the superior choice over shingles when it comes to roofing. For more information on metal roofing in the panhandle of Florida, visit www.wsmetalroofing.com today!